In 2013 the then-prime minister David Cameron called the massacre a 'deeply shameful' event
cannot make up its collective mind on Brexit after three years, perhaps it is not surprising that ministers are still “reflecting” on whether or not to issue an apology for the Amritsar massacre after one hundred. That was the verdict from the government benches during a recent debate on the subject in the House of Lords, ahead of the centenary on April 13th.
On that day in 1919, General Reginald Dyer ordered 50 men under his command to fire into a crowd of people at Amritsar, the spiritual home of Sikhism, in north-west India. In just ten minutes his troops fired 1,650 rounds, killing at least 370 and wounding over 1,000. Whereas the general claimed he was forestalling an insurrection, those gathered in the public garden of Jallianwala Bagh were in fact unarmed, listening peacefully to some speeches.
That may cause surprisingly little indignation in India. Not much fuss is being made over the centenary in the city itself. Insofar as the term “Amritsar” marks a harrowing episode in the history of India, these days it tends to recall the bloody partition of India and Pakistan in 1947. Families of Hindu Punjabis who fled Lahore via Amritsar suffered great depredations on the way. A museum devoted to preserving the memory of partition opened in 2017.
Some, like Rudrangshu Mukherjee, a historian at Ashoka University, are actually irritated by the notion that Britain might apologise for the incident. It would be good for the British to remember that Dyer’s actions constituted “a national tragedy of enormous proportion”, says Mr Mukherjee. Yet Amritsar was just one example of British misrule. Mr Mukherjee warns that “you could make an apology about this specific incident without acknowledging a broader reality—which would be of no help.
With national elections set to start on April 11th, Indians have more pressing matters in mind. Narendra Modi, the prime minister, controls the story of Indian nationalism these days, and has little use for the history of the anti-colonial struggle . The Congress party, now in opposition, would traditionally stoke the embers of the anti-British campaigns, which it led. But it is trying hard to appeal to new voters, desperate for jobs and otherwise far from the memory of the freedom struggle.
Canada Latest News, Canada Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
The politics of apologising for AmritsarDuring the 1919 Amritsar massacre, British troops fired 1,650 rounds, killing at least 370 and wounding over 1,000 people
Read more »
If Anyone Understands How Virginia Feels Right Now, It Should Be Auburn FansThere are notable similarities between Virginia's miraculous wins in the last two rounds of the NCAA tournament and Auburn's back-to-back football miracles in 2013. However, the Cavaliers surely hope the similarities end there. Auburn's remarkable 2013 season ended without a national championship.
Read more »
Europe’s other migration crisisEmigration towards the continent’s core takes internationalists from the places that need them most
Read more »
Trump says Egypt has a 'great president'. Here are Sisi's greatest hitsFrom going after a comedic puppet for Muslim Brotherhood sympathies, to a deteriorating economy - After Trump praised the 'great' job the Egyptian president is doing, we look at some of Sisi's biggest achievements.
Read more »
Don’t Count on a Hollywood Showdown at SonyHeard on the Street: Daniel Loeb seems to be taking another shot at Sony. He failed to rally support for a spinoff of movie and music assets in 2013 and he may fail again.
Read more »
Enjoy that raise. This might be as good as it getsEven as employers kept hiring and the unemployment rate fell to multidecade lows, the demand for workers failed to translate into higher pay. For most of the period starting in 2010 and ending in 2013, wage growth hovered below 2%. Lately, though, things have started to move.
Read more »
The politics of apologising for AmritsarDuring the 1919 Amritsar massacre, British troops fired 1,650 rounds, killing at least 370 and wounding over 1,000 people
Read more »