+34
Alberta leaders on both sides of the aisle debated about separation Friday evening, joining CBC Radio’s Edmonton AM host Tara McCarthy for a panel discussion ahead of the provincial referendum.
Alberta leaders on both sides of the aisle debated about separation Friday evening, joining CBC Radio’s Edmonton AM host Tara McCarthy for a panel discussion ahead of the provincial referendum.
The audio version of this article is generated by AI-based technology. Mispronunciations can occur. We are working with our partners to continually review and improve the results. From left: former Alberta premier Jason Kenney, lawyer and educator Marie Gordon and lawyer Keith Wilson.
They joined CBC Radio's Edmonton AM host Tara McCarthy, right, to talk about the Oct. 19 referendum. host Tara McCarthy for a panel discussion ahead of the provincial referendum. During Friday's event at the Horowitz Theatre, Keith Wilson, leader of the pro-independence group Let Alberta Decide, advocated for the potential benefits of secession. Former Alberta premier Jason Kenney and lawyer and educator Marie Gordon made their cases for staying in Confederation.
Kenney pointed to the Quebec referendum of 1980, where nearly 60 per cent voted against pursuing secession.
“That didn't stop the separatists; that just encouraged them,” he said during the panel, which was put on by CBC Edmonton and the University of Alberta Students' Union . “I'm concerned that a large minority vote will simply turn this into a permanently divisive fact in our politics. ”UCP MLA says he’s voted in favour of Alberta holding binding referendum on independence “We have a legal constitutional pathway. We have reasonable expectations.
We have honorable goals, whether you disagree with them or not," he said.
"I think this conversation has started. I think it's going to continue. I think it's going to get more refined. ”Kenney noted several other concerns about separation, including what it could cost Alberta's economic growth.
“If we were to trip into this — into the negotiations that Keith wants — then suddenly the pro-growth tailwinds would turn into very substantial headwinds, represented by political uncertainty,” he said. “What investors crave in this Trumpian world more than anything is political certainty, and we would become the opposite. We would become a billboard for uncertainty, which would at least slow down — and potentially freeze — a lot of that prospective investment.
” Friday's panel was organized by CBC Edmonton and the University of Alberta Students' Union . “Alberta is an economic powerhouse, we're the only growing region of the country — and we're growing despite laws from Ottawa that would hold us back,” Wilson said. Kenney also raised that the relationship with First Nations groups could be harmed, if Albertans vote to initiate the legal process to hold a binding referendum on separation.
“The vast majority of them are commercial partners in — and often equity co-owners of — pipelines, major production,” he said. “If Keith gets his way, … suddenly that positive relationship flips and we go from First Nations being allies and advocates of economic growth and resource development, to hitting the brakes on everything because they take an entirely reasonable position. ”I'm an Indigenous entrepreneur fighting to keep my business.
Alberta needs change, but not separatism Wilson believes the reports looking into the viability of an independent Alberta aren’t entirely reliable, he said, suggesting they all focused on the worst possible outcomes. Albertans will be asked 10 questions in the Oct. 19 referendum. Only one regards the province's place within Canada. The other nine relate to immigration and the Constitution.
Wilson feels the separation question is the most important, because the others don't "lead to a binding mechanism to force the federal government and the provinces to come to the table and look at constitutional change," he said. But Gordon, the lawyer and educator, disagreed. She said she's concerned the other nine questions will send a message — both about immigrants and the federal government.
“These questions are really intriguing in terms of, not only what they ask, but what they say," she said. Five questions revolve around immigration policy, including whether the Alberta government should have more control and if non-permanent residents, at least for a time, should pay to access certain social services, like health care.
“I'm really worried about scapegoating and blaming newcomers that is embedded in each of those five questions,” Gordon said. Albertans divided on immigration, while half still undecided on 9 non-separation questions: poll The remaining four questions focus on constitutional issues, such as judicial appointments and abolishing the Senate. Gordon called them a "very interesting blaming exercises," saying each of the four places blame on the federal government, Senate and judges.
Alberta referendum panel at U of A brings out heavy hitters Subscribe to CBC’s Your Alberta newsletter for a weekly round-up of the best news stories, video and audio content from around your province.
Canada Latest News, Canada Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Alberta’s top court upholds convictions of leaders of the COVID-19 blockadeChris Carbert and Anthony Olienick were charged in 2022 and convicted by a jury in 2024
Read more »
Alberta Health Services investigates E. coli outbreak at Kinjo Sushi and Grill in Mahogany, CalgaryAlberta Health Services is investigating a gastrointestinal illness outbreak linked to shiga toxin-producing E. coli at Kinjo Sushi and Grill-Mahogany in southeast Calgary, with four confirmed cases and two probable cases.
Read more »
RCMP Investigate Significant Diesel Theft in Central AlbertaRCMP are investigating a significant diesel theft from a central Alberta gas station. Diesel prices have reached historic highs, prompting warnings about fuel thefts.
Read more »
Alberta Referendum 2025: Students Debate Immigration and Separation Ahead of Oct. 19 VoteAhead of Alberta's Oct. 19 referendum, University of Alberta students share views on immigration and separation, with a CBC Edmonton panel discussion set for Oct. 2.
Read more »