CA
Advertisement

Letters to the editor: ‘Albertans deserve clarity, efficiency and unity, not processes that amplify polarization.’ Letters to the editor for Oct. 12

Letters to the editor: ‘Albertans deserve clarity, efficiency and unity, not processes that amplify polarization.’ Letters to the editor for Oct. 12
Letters To The Editor · Nopolly
Advertisement

In today’s letters to the editor: Global Affairs; the UN; Alberta; MAID; Catholic hospitals; Cornell and Hockey Canada

Real talk Re “Canada drops sponsorship of conference that cites U.S. as foreign-interference actor” : For the first time in decades, we have a Prime Minister courageous enough to tell it like it is.

Meanwhile, Global Affairs prefers to sit on the fence because “Ottawa wasn’t comfortable with the framing of some of the panels. ” Comfortable? The U.S. President and his administration have been lying steadily – that’s disinformation – about Canada, Canadians and Canadian trade figures for nearly two years. Canada requires a truthful, global and noisy defence from Global Affairs, not the comforting clink of teacups.

Also read'Extra stress': Tension peaking among Albertans as separation vote…

Robert Fripp Toronto Unhelpful? Re “The United Nations needs more Canada, not less” : I share the enthusiasm for the necessity of the United Nations, but I fear the optimistic suggestions are besides the point. How can the UN actually end conflicts and convince member states to create peaceful conditions?

“There were more interstate wars in 2025 than at any time since just after the Second World War. Hopefully the conflicts that persist today will end with truces or peace treaties and that is when peacekeepers will likely be needed from Canada. ” I find this wishful thinking. Russia, Lebanon, Israel: Examples of continuing interstate wars involving UN members abound, and these are just the conflicts most in the news.

To me, more wars means the UN has failed.

Advertisement

“UN boots on the ground” only puts soldiers in danger in situations of faint hope which are often just recesses in continuing wars. I do not see reasons for optimism for more truces and peace. Michael Levin Toronto Political process Re “The Alberta referendum: a pointless, futile stunt, just like the last one” : Greater provincial control over immigration could have been achieved by drafting and passing legislation.

Most of the other issues raised in the referendum questions could also have been debated and resolved within normal parliamentary processes. Even the constitutional question could have been shared with other governments, as the referendum question itself suggests, and addressed through intergovernmental discussion rather than public vote. In reality, no referendum should be required.

There is the example of former premier Jason Kenney’s referendum on daylight saving time: Albertans voted No by a narrow margin, yet the current government later changed the policy unilaterally. When governments choose referendums for issues that could be handled through legislation, debate and intergovernmental co-operation, it risks turning governance into political theatre. Albertans deserve clarity, efficiency and unity, not processes that amplify polarization.

A straightforward legislative path could have strengthened trust instead of straining it, and saved money and effort. Anas Khan Beaumont, Alta. On MAID Re “Refusing MAID for mental disorders will come at a terrible cost” : A louder message could not have been sent. In 2026, it seems doctors and legislators still believe that ailments from the neck down need care, compassion and understanding, and are therefore eligible for medical assistance in dying.

Everything from the neck up? Good luck. Isn’t it interesting that so many psychologists and psychiatrists do not seem to be standing up for people with mental illness. But we are happy to have institutions to house them and suicide hotlines.

When will mental illness rise to the level of all other diseases? Joe-ann Barisa Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ont. The federal government’s forthcoming legislation barring medical assistance in dying for mental illness is likely to be a stop-gap measure until the Supreme Court rules on whether a mentally competent person can access MAID due to mental illness.

However, this should not stop governments from making needed investments in mental health services so that it is less likely people will seek MAID due to gaps in mental health care. Steve Lurie CM ; former executive director, Canadian Mental Health Association Toronto Faith in medicine Re “It’s well past time for Catholic hospitals to be secularized” : How can we maintain that the state is neutral in matters pertaining to personal morals – regarding, for example, the abortion debate – if it would fund hospitals that will perform abortions but refuse to fund hospitals that will not?

Advertisement

Stephen McNamee Ottawa This raises legitimate concerns about patients navigating a complicated system. People facing serious illness should know what care is available and receive help accessing it. But the remedy, secularizing Catholic hospitals, would remove something Canadians continue to need. The assertion that institutions have no conscience sidesteps how they function.

Hospitals adopt ethical commitments which arise from people organizing themselves to serve a public purpose. The collective work of religious communities deserves consideration when deciding what diversity our health care system can accommodate. Requiring every publicly funded hospital to administer procedures that violate religious commitments would leave faithful Canadians without institutions reflecting their understanding of care. Let’s keep in mind medical assistance in dying remains widely available and accessible in a health care system that includes religious institutions.

Most critically, this column does not answer a simple question: Why does providing widespread access require every institution to participate? Ray Pennings Executive vice-president and co-founder, Cardus; Hamilton Do better Re “In the Cornell and Hockey Canada cases, institutional failure is a common thread” : Another parallel between these two examples of alleged group sexual assault stands out to me: Both involve some members of men’s sports teams.

Evidently, too often, male team culture emphasizes the worst forms of masculinity. The most general message I get is that this culture must be changed. Richard Harris Hamilton While it is appropriate to call out failures in both these examples to properly bring these cases to justice, we as a society should wonder at our own failures as parents, teachers and communities in teaching and solidifying moral behaviour in our young adults.

The 20-year-old brain may not be fully developed, all while being inundated with vile images on social media. Our response must be strong from the earliest ages: We should do a better job at talking about what is morally unaccepted behaviour with age-appropriate discussions. It should happen often throughout development, so that when they are in situations of groupthink, they can draw on a foundation of knowledge.

What are we not teaching our children that they themselves may not be morally sickened by these acts? Cheryl Altman Collingwood, Ont. .................................................................................................................................. Letters to the Editor should be exclusive to The Globe and Mail.

Include your name, address and daytime phone number. Keep letters to 150 words or fewer. Letters may be edited for length and clarity. To submit a letter by e-mail, click here: letters@globeandmail.com

globeandmail#5 in Canada

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here.

Advertisement

More on Noastack

See all

Latest News · Canada

See all
Up nextAlbertans Face Rising Tension As October 19 Separation Vote Nears