+34
A jury has found that an Ottawa-based lawyer who represented survivors of St. Anne’s Residential School defamed the Timmins-based law firm Wallbridge Wallbridge in letters she wrote more than ten years ago.
Estimated 3 minutes The audio version of this article is generated by AI-based technology. Mispronunciations can occur. We are working with our partners to continually review and improve the results.
Lawyer Fay Brunning seen outside court in Toronto on Wednesday, Dec. 14, 2016. A jury has found that an Ottawa-based lawyer who represented survivors of St. Anne’s Residential School defamed the Timmins-based law firm Wallbridge Wallbridge in letters she wrote more than ten years ago. At the time, Brunning was representing clients previously represented by the Wallbridge firm, helping them to re-apply for compensation under the Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement.
In a series of emails, Brunning inquired about files from an OPP investigation, and asked whether Wallbridge had signed an agreement with the federal government and the Catholic Church to not disclose those documents. The jury agreed with the plaintiff that Brunning’s words injured the firm’s reputation when she made the accusation, and that it was substantially untrue. In other letters, Brunning alleged the firm's lawyers had access to updated files and failed to use that evidence to help clients.
While the jury found no damages against the principals of the firm, James and Almeida Wallbridge, it did assess nominal damages at $50,000 for the firm of Wallbridge, Wallbridge. During closing arguments, the lawyer representing Wallbridge, Wallbridge, told the jury that to suggest the firm was negligent in serving clients, was a serious blow to the firm’s reputation.
“At the end of the day, what the defence has done, has picked at every sore that they found, and was unsuccessful. It doesn’t add up to negligence,” said Geoff Adair. Adair said while a couple of Brunning’s accusations were couched as opinions, several were stated as fact.
Brunning’s lawyer Tina Hill argued during the trial that Brunning was acting as counsel on behalf of her clients and their best interests, that the comments were not spread to a wide audience, and that there was no evidence of harm caused to law firm. As for the accusation that Wallbridge, Wallbridge signed an agreement with the federal government and the Catholic Church to not disclose evidence, Hill argued Brunning believed the accusation to be true, based on circumstantial evidence.
But in 2022, she said Brunning learned it wasn't true, and issued an apology to seven people and also sent it to some media outlets. Kate RutherfordKate Rutherford is a reporter with CBC News in Sudbury, covering northern Ontario. News tips can be sent to kate.rutherford@cbc.ca
Canada Latest News, Canada Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Saskatchewan Roughriders Acquire Kicker Brett Lauther From Ottawa RedblacksThe Saskatchewan Roughriders have re-signed veteran kicker Brett Lauther by acquiring him from the Ottawa Redblacks in exchange for a fifth-round pick in the 2027 CFL draft. The 35-year-old, who previously played eight seasons in Regina and helped secure last year's Grey Cup, has been highly effective this season with a 32-of-34 field goal conversion rate. The trade marks a return for Lauther after he signed with struggling Ottawa earlier in the year, while the Roughriders had relied on rookie Alex Hale for the start of the season.
Read more »
Ottawa's Fall Housing Market Offers Buyers More Choice as Inventory RisesOttawa's fall housing market brings increased inventory and less competition, giving buyers more time to compare properties and secure mortgage rates. Sellers face greater competition and need to attract qualified buyers despite rising interest rates.
Read more »
Grand jury indicts Ivanna Ortiz in Rihanna home shooting on attempted murder countsA Florida woman accused of firing a rifle at Rihanna and A$AP Rocky's home has been indicted on attempted murder and more than a dozen other felony counts. A judge ordered her held on $2.6 million bail after she pleaded not guilty.
Read more »
Global humanitarian aid needs to be restructured as countries cut donations, report saysOttawa-based refugee council launches initiative to revamp international aid efforts
Read more »