Commentary: Anwar’s call for need-based affirmative action is popular and appealing but profoundly flawed

Canada News News

Commentary: Anwar’s call for need-based affirmative action is popular and appealing but profoundly flawed
Canada Latest News,Canada Headlines
  • 📰 ChannelNewsAsia
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 65 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 29%
  • Publisher: 66%

Without a clear grasp of the system of race-based preferences in place and feasible reform options, Anwar Ibrahim’s project will lead to ...

The rich do not merit special treatment; rich Bumiputeras should not be further enriched or granted race-based privileges. Hence, Malaysia ought to take away race-based policies and replace them with need-based policies.

Malaysia’s expansive pro-Bumiputera system grants preferential treatment in four key sectors: Higher education, employment in the civil service and government-linked corporations , public procurement and enterprise development, and wealth ownership. Unless he clarifies his thinking, he will most likely end up backtracking, recommitting to the existing Bumiputera agenda in a defensive manner, and ultimately disappointing all sides.

Think of the Malay civil servant, who most probably earns a good wage, yet for whom preferential policies have enhanced the chances for promotion. What does taking away race-based preferences entail for her?Students walking under their umbrellas at Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia The spectre of need-based affirmative action, presented through sweeping statements with utterly vague implications, without specific plans or details of alternative policies to be rolled out, induces fear and loathing.

Favouring the poor in the award of contracts or promotion of civil servants defies logic and invites trouble; for instance, a poorer contractor might be an incompetent one. But granting preferential university entry to children of low-income households instead of Bumiputera households makes sense, and can realistically be executed.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

ChannelNewsAsia /  🏆 6. in SG

Canada Latest News, Canada Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

US, Canada need to open eyes to Pan Am GamesUS, Canada need to open eyes to Pan Am GamesThe United States and Canada need to open their eyes to what is happening outside their own borders if the Pan American Games is to get the kind ...
Read more »

Boeing to change 737 MAX flight-control software to address flaw: SourcesBoeing to change 737 MAX flight-control software to address flaw: SourcesBoeing Co plans further changes to the software architecture of the 737 MAX flight-control system to address a flaw discovered after a test in ...
Read more »

Commentary: In the eye of a trade war storm but China still takes the long viewCommentary: In the eye of a trade war storm but China still takes the long viewChinese officials are not about to bet on the 2020 US presidential election in formulating their strategic response to the trade conflict, says ...
Read more »

Commentary: An intense urge to hurt someone, when anger gets out of hand for someCommentary: An intense urge to hurt someone, when anger gets out of hand for someTwo cases of anger management show why keeping our anger in check is critical – and achievable, says IMH’s Haanusia Prithivi Raj.
Read more »

Ronald Reagan calls Africans ‘monkeys’ in call to NixonRonald Reagan calls Africans ‘monkeys’ in call to NixonWASHINGTON Then-California Governor Ronald Reagan made racist remarks about Africans, calling them 'monkeys' in a newly-discovered taped conversation with US President Richard Nixon. The tape of the October 1971 phone call was unearthed by Mr Tim Naftali, former director of...
Read more »

Commentary: The long, winding road back to a US-China trade dealCommentary: The long, winding road back to a US-China trade dealStill, talks between US President Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping remain positive and upbeat as gestures to meet halfway produce greater ...
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-08-30 09:36:48