Following a complaint from the Watershed Watch Salmon Society, Canada's Office of the Information Commissioner ordered Fisheries and Oceans Canada to fully disclose the records from its 2022 report on sea lice. The order comes after a two-year struggle to access the data, which the commissioner determined was wrongly withheld.
Canada's Office of the Information Commissioner has ordered Fisheries and Oceans Canada to fully disclose the records in its 2022 report into sea lice. The information commissioner's final report, released Tuesday (Jan. 28), followed a complaint from Watershed Watch Salmon Society, alleging Fisheries and Oceans Canada has improperly withheld information in response to an access request for data that was analyzed in a 2023 sea-lice report.
The commissioner Caroline Maynard issued an order to the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans Diane Lebouthillier on Jan. 20. The DFO's acting director of Access to Information and Privacy Division gave Maynard notice on Jan. 22 that the department would be implementing the order and fully disclose the information to the complainant. \The 2023 Canadian Science Advisory Secretariat Science Response from Fisheries and Oceans Canada concluded that there was no significant link between parasitic lice infestations at B.C. salmon farms and infestations in wild salmon exposed to those farms in four regions. It added that the lack of statistical significance implies that the occurrence of lice infestation on wild migrating juvenile Pacific salmon cannot be explained solely by infestation pressure from farm-sourced copepodids. In a news release from the Watershed Watch Salmon Society Thursday, it says that since the release of the 2023 Canadian Science Advisory Secretariat Science Response, it has pursued multiple avenues to access the data used in the report. That includes an access to information request and an environmental petition to Canada's auditor general. In 2023, a group of 16 professors and research scientists sent an open letter to then-minister of Fisheries and Oceans Canada Joyce Murray. The group said they had serious concerns about the processes in the report, and that it falls far short of the standards of credible independent peer review and publishable science. \Watershed Watch Salmon Society senior science and policy analyst Stan Proboszcz said that Canadians deserve transparency. 'It should not be this difficult to access information about an industry operating in public waters,' Proboszcz said. “This two-year struggle for the truth begs the question, ‘what are they trying to hide about the harmful impacts fish farms have on B.C. wild salmon?’” First Nations Wild Salmon Alliance chair Bob Chamberlin said Nations he worked with in the B.C. Aquaculture Transition Planning process made formal requests for this data two years ago and never received it or other similar information. 'Key DFO staff defend this industry at the expense of the honour of the Crown.' The release added the data has not yet been released. The records are five Excel spreadsheets, with four of those containing only temperature and salinity data. During the investigation, Fisheries and Oceans conceded that the temperature and salinity data provided by its Pacific Region office could be disclosed. The department also determined it could release most of the columns in the fifth spreadsheet containing sea-lice data, other than four columns that would allow for calculation of the number of fish per farm pen at a given point in time. There were three third parties identified by Fisheries and Oceans that the information in the spreadsheets relate to: Cermaq Canada, Mowi Canada West and Grieg Seafood British Columbia. The commissioner's office tried to get representation from all three, but only received a response from Mowi. The data related to Mowi was exclusively about temperature and salinity, which Fisheries and Oceans said could be disclosed. The population and sea-lice data related to Cermaq, but the company didn't respond to the commissioner. According to the commissioner's investigation, when an institution withholds information related to third parties, they bear the burden of showing that refusing to grant access is justified. However, the commissioner determined that the complaint was well founded, with the information not shown to be objectively confidential or supplied by a third party, as well as it wasn't shown that the government intended to publish the information within 90 days of the access request being made
SEALIICE FISHERIES AND OCEANS CANADA ACCESS TO INFORMATION WATERSHED WATCH SALMON SOCIETY CANADA's OFFICE OF THE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
Canada Latest News, Canada Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Solar Panel Company Sues Canada Border Agency Over DetentionCharge Solar Renewables Inc. sued the CBSA, alleging that the detention of solar panels from China caused them to lose market share.
Read more »
Canada Border Agency Defends Detention of Solar Panels Over Forced Labour ConcernsThe Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) is defending its detention of nearly 50 containers of solar panels from a Victoria, B.C., company, arguing it acted lawfully and in 'good faith' over concerns of forced labour. Charge Solar Renewables Inc. sued the CBSA in Federal Court, alleging the detention caused it to lose its dominant market share. While the shipments were eventually released, the CBSA maintains it owes no 'duty of care' to importers and that its decisions are based on legal obligations, not commercial impacts.
Read more »
Solar Panel Importer Sues Canada Border Agency Over DetentionCharge Solar Renewables Inc. is suing the Canada Border Services Agency for detaining nearly 50 containers of solar panels from China, alleging the detention caused them to lose market share. The company claims the border agency acted negligently, while the agency argues it acted lawfully and in good faith, citing concerns about forced labor. The lawsuit raises questions about the balance between national security and the impact on businesses.
Read more »
Canada Border Service Agency Defends Detention of Solar PanelsThe Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) insists it acted lawfully when detaining almost 50 containers of solar panels from China. Charge Solar Renewables Inc. is suing the agency for alleged negligence, claiming the detention caused them to lose market share.
Read more »
Canada Revenue Agency to Administer Capital Gains Tax Despite Parliamentary ProrogationThe Canadian government intends to continue the administration of a proposed capital gains tax, even though Parliament is currently prorogued. The finance department asserts that parliamentary convention allows for the tax to be implemented upon the tabling of a notice of ways and means motion, which the Liberals did in September.
Read more »
Canada Revenue Agency to Continue Administering Capital Gains Tax Despite ProrogationThe Canadian government announced that the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) will continue to administer the capital gains tax, despite Parliament being prorogued. The finance department stated that the policy will be effective as soon as the government tables a notice of ways and means motion.
Read more »