The B.C. Court of Appeal has struck down a provincial law designed to expedite a supportive housing development in Vancouver, deeming it unconstitutional for interfering with the court's role.
The B.C. Court of Appeal has ruled that a law passed by the provincial government to stave off opposition to a supportive housing development in the Vancouver neighbourhood of Kitsilano is unconstitutional. The provincial government had adopted the law at the request of the City of Vancouver in 2023 to push through a 12-storey housing development at Arbutus Street, featuring units open to low income residents and users of support services.
But the Arbutus development was opposed by the Kitsilano Coalition for Children & Family Safety Society, which took the city to court over its in-principle approval of a rezoning to allow the project to go ahead. Monday’s ruling says the provincial government “evidently became concerned” the litigation could delay the rezoning, so it passed the Municipal Enabling and Validating Act to facilitate the project. The B.C. Supreme Court upheld the law in November last year, but the community group appealed, arguing the law crossed the line in bypassing the court’s “supervisory role” enshrined by Constitution. The three-judge appellate panel found the legislation “amounted to interference” with the court’s adjudicative role. Peter Gall, the coalition’s lawyers, said Monday that the ruling is a “very important rule-of-law decision.” “It affirms the constitutional principle that the legislature can’t take away or usurp the right of citizens to challenge governmental action,” Gall said. “That’s what the legislature attempted to do here with the law it passed.” The ruling said the case wasn’t about whether the housing crisis “requires action or whether the proposed development should proceed” – the “sole issue” was whether the province infringed upon the role of the court. Gall said the coalition challenged the validity of the public hearing into the project, and did so by going to court. The provincial government “simply said that ‘we deem the public hearing to be in compliance with the law,”’ Gall said
LAW CONSTITUTION HOUSING VANCOUVER COURT
Canada Latest News, Canada Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
B.C. Court of Appeal Rules Provincial Law to Advance Housing Project UnconstitutionalThe B.C. Court of Appeal has declared a provincial law facilitating a supportive housing development in Vancouver's Kitsilano neighborhood unconstitutional, citing interference with the court's role.
Read more »
B.C. Court of Appeal Rules Provincial Law to Facilitate Supportive Housing UnconstitutionalThe B.C. Court of Appeal has declared a provincial law, enacted to expedite a supportive housing development in Vancouver's Kitsilano neighborhood, unconstitutional. The law, passed in 2023 at the City of Vancouver's request, aimed to bypass legal challenges to the Arbutus Street project, which faced opposition from the Kitsilano Coalition for Children & Family Safety Society. The court ruled that the legislation interfered with the judiciary's role, emphasizing that the core issue was the infringement on the court's authority, not the merits of the housing project itself.
Read more »
B.C. Court of Appeal Rules Supportive Housing Law UnconstitutionalThe B.C. Court of Appeal has declared a law passed by the provincial government to facilitate a supportive housing project in Vancouver's Kitsilano neighbourhood as unconstitutional. The ruling stems from a challenge by the Kitsilano Coalition for Children & Family Safety Society, who argued that the law bypassed the court's role in overseeing rezoning decisions.
Read more »
Canada Tightens Clean Electricity Rules Despite Provincial PushbackCanada's federal government is implementing new regulations to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from electricity grids, aiming to phase out natural gas power generation by 2035. Despite resistance from provinces heavily reliant on fossil fuels, the rules have been revised to offer greater flexibility.
Read more »
U.S. court dismisses appeal in Donald Trump classified documents caseThe order from the U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeals means both federal cases against Trump have now been dropped as he prepares to return to the White House on Jan 20.
Read more »
Canada's top court dismisses appeal in Ontario drug trafficking caseCanada's highest court has dismissed the appeal of a Guelph, Ont., man convicted of drug trafficking after police impersonated a drug dealer in order to arrest him.
Read more »