A new message to Trudeau: There must be no 'acceding to the demands of hostage-takers' - Macleans.ca

Canada News News

A new message to Trudeau: There must be no 'acceding to the demands of hostage-takers' - Macleans.ca
Canada Latest News,Canada Headlines
  • 📰 macleans
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 91 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 40%
  • Publisher: 71%

While the Meng case reveals a major fault line among Canadian thinkers, a second group has written to Trudeau urging the PM to defend the rule of law

A man holds a sign bearing photographs of Kovrig and Spavor outside B.C. Supreme Court where Meng was attending a hearing in Vancouver on Jan. 21, 2020

Yet some in Canada’s international affairs community reacted with horror at the suggestion, despite the plight of the detainees, that experts including three former foreign ministers would recommend that Canada turn back on its commitment to judicial independence in the case. Since these arrests, some have argued that Ottawa should simply release Meng in exchange for the release of Kovrig and Spavor, most recently in interviews with and letters signed by a number of high-profile Canadians. These arguments are not only wrong in principle but would involve Canada betraying important values and letting down a number of our key allies.

Historically we have only declined to extradite in very narrow and exceptional cases. What is being asked of us in Meng’s case is that we abandon this honourable tradition, not because of some flaw in the extradition case brought by the Americans, but because China is holding our citizens hostage. The integrity of the rule of law and our judicial system requires that we decline to do so.

Nor is this just about Canada. China has detained citizens from countries like Australia, Japan, Great Britain and the U.S. for political ends. If Canada capitulates to Chinese hostage-taking, we would be abandoning solidarity with our allies and making ourselves a weak link when it comes to dealing with Chinese aggression.

Holding firm against China’s scandalous treatment of Kovrig and Spavor does not exhaust our options. Ottawa is rightly working with our allies to denounce China’s illegal hostage diplomacy and to improve the deplorable conditions in which Kovrig and Spavor are being held. Yet more can still be done. For instance, Ottawa should issue a warning to Canadians that it cannot guarantee their safety when travelling in China.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

macleans /  🏆 19. in CA

Canada Latest News, Canada Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Inside the Canadian establishment's fight with Trudeau over China - Macleans.caInside the Canadian establishment's fight with Trudeau over China - Macleans.caHow a letter from a superbly-connected group of Canadians happened, and hoped to pressure the Prime Minister into releasing Meng Wanzhou
Read more »

John Ivison: Trudeau is right to reject hostage diplomacy with ChinaJohn Ivison: Trudeau is right to reject hostage diplomacy with ChinaTrudeau\u0027s resolution should come as no surprise. After all, he said that even if his children were held hostage, he would not compromise his office to save them
Read more »

Dr. Catherine Hankins and Dr. David Naylor in conversation with Paul Wells: Maclean's Live - Macleans.caDr. Catherine Hankins and Dr. David Naylor in conversation with Paul Wells: Maclean's Live - Macleans.caTwo scientists on the COVID19 Immunity Task Force will join Paul Wells to discuss coronavirus antibody test development progress—and the dangers that still lie ahead—on July 2 7 p.m. EDT via Zoom. MacleansLive Presented by CdnBankers, w/ CanadasNAC
Read more »

Hal Johnson: 'Yes, there is systemic racism in Canada' - Macleans.caHal Johnson: 'Yes, there is systemic racism in Canada' - Macleans.caHal Johnson: For my entire life I've had to conform to society in order to succeed. I've become a chameleon. Change will happen when the people in power are no longer afraid to put people of colour in key decision-making roles.
Read more »

You’ve been breathing all wrong - Macleans.caYou’ve been breathing all wrong - Macleans.caHey mouth-breathers! Use your nose to boost your immune system, your circulation, your mood and even your sexual functioning
Read more »

Fort McMurray, the city that battles back - Macleans.caFort McMurray, the city that battles back - Macleans.caFire, flood, plague. A string of calamities has revealed the resilience and sense of unity that Fort McMurray, Alta. spent decades building
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-02-12 14:05:30